Analyzing the Effectiveness of Rehabilitation vs. Punishment in the Criminal Justice System

Authors

  • Fazail Asrar Ahmed Assistant Professor, Faculty of Law, Grand Asian University Sialkot. fazailkh11@gmail.com Asad Irfan King's College London Asadirfan07@gmail.com AQSA Urooj aqsa_tahir92@yahoo.com The Islamia University of Bahwalapur Hassan Latif shaikh. University of Sindh Jamshoro
  • Asad Irfan King's College London
  • Aqsa Urooj The Islamia University of Bahwalapur, Pakistan
  • Hassan Latif Shaikh University of Sindh, Jamshoro, Pakistan

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.47067/real.v8i1.400

Keywords:

Rehabilitation, Punishment, Criminal Justice, Restorative Justice, Recidivism, Pakistan

Abstract

This study examines the effectiveness of rehabilitation versus punishment in Pakistan's criminal justice system, focusing on overcrowded prisons, limited rehabilitation programs, and social stigma among former offenders. A qualitative approach was employed, employing case studies, literature reviews, and legal documents to explore existing rehabilitation programs, punitive measures, and restorative justice measures. Analysis of data revealed systemic issues, such as inadequate funding, untrained personnel, and weak post-release support that limit the effectiveness of rehabilitation. Results show that punitive measures are not enough to deter crime since socio-economic factors such as poverty and unemployment remain significant drivers. Rehabilitation programs, though promising, must be extended, funded better, and coupled with restorative justice measures. The study recommends policy changes to balance punishment and rehabilitation, public awareness campaigns, and post-release reintegration assistance to reduce recidivism. These changes can make Pakistan's criminal justice system more sustainable and fair.

References

Ahmad, W., Chengbin, L., Mahmood, R., Suleman, R. M. F., Mahmood, S., & Mahmood, U. (2024). Exploring the Integration of Restorative Justice into the Criminal Justice System of Pakistan. Qualitative Research.

Ahmar, M. (2024). Criminal Justice Reform in Islamic and International Law: Towards a Unified Framework. International Journal for Conventional and Non-Conventional Warfare, 1(2), 44-55.

AllahRakha, N. Modernizing Punishment: Comparative Analysis on Pakistan's Penal Code. Available at SSRN 5036330.

Andrews, D. A., & Bonta, J. (2010). Rehabilitating criminal justice policy and practice. Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, 16(1), 39.

Awais, F., & Shah, N. A. (2024). A Critical Appraisal of the Criminal Justice System's Framework in Pakistan: Options for Reducing Abuse of Process. Traditional Journal of Law and Social Sciences, 3(02), 71-85.

Azeem, H. M., Umar, M., & Sultan, M. S. (2023). Private Prosecution in Pakistan: Analysis of the Nur Elahi case and its implications for Public Prosecution. Pakistan JL Analysis & Wisdom, 2, 509.

Belkin, J., Brauner, R., & Cassidy, G. (1975). Programming approach to the criminal justice system. INFOR: Information Systems and Operational Research, 13(3), 227-247.

Bytko, S. Y., & Varygin, A. (2019). Some methodological issues of evaluating the effectiveness of the preventive impact of criminal punishments. Perm U. Herald Jurid. Sci., 43, 146.

Chishti, N. (2023). Criminal Justice Systems: Comparing Approaches to Punishment and Rehabilitation. SAUS-Journal of Management Sciences and Commerce, 1(1), 19-26.

Cook, P. J. (1977). Punishment and crime: a critique of current findings concerning the preventive effects of punishment. Law & Contemp. Probs., 41, 164.

Cullen, F. T., & Gendreau, P. (2000). Assessing correctional rehabilitation: Policy, practice, and prospects. Criminal justice, 3(1), 299-370.

DeLuca, H., Miller, T. J., & Wiedemann, C. F. (1991). Punishment vs. rehabilitation: A proposal for revising sentencing practices. Fed. Probation, 55, 37.

Ehrlich, I. (1981). On the usefulness of controlling individuals: an economic analysis of rehabilitation, incapacitation and deterrence. The American Economic Review, 71(3), 307-322.

GACINYA, J. (2024). CRIMINAL PUNISHMENT. Reviewed Journal of Social Science & Humanities, 5(1), 93–120-193–120.

Ghazi, A., & Salamat, U. F. (2023). HONOUR KILLING AND CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM IN PAKISTAN: REFLECTIONS ON INCIDENTS IN GUJRANWALA, 2012-2023. Review of Human Rights, 9(1), 118-142.

Govindan, D. (2022). Retribution, Rehabilitation and Restoration-Working towards the Goals of Criminal Justice. Part 1 Indian J. Integrated Rsch. L., 2, 1.

Haidar, B., Begum, A., & Ali, M. (2023). A critical appraisal of the juvenile justice system in Pakistan: Challenges and the way forward. International Journal of Human and Society, 3(3), 405-412.

Jabeen, T. (2021). Challenges in the Prevention of Child Maltreatment in Pakistan: an Interplay of the Culture and the Context. International Journal on Child Maltreatment: Research, Policy and Practice, 4(4), 421-437.

Khalid, Z., Lee, R., & Wall, B. W. (2024). The use of neurobiological evidence in sentencing mitigation. Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 42(2), 65-78.

Khan, M. I., Nisar, A., & Kanwel, S. (2023). From Punishment to Progress: The Legal Evolution of Criminal Rehabilitation. Pakistan JL Analysis & Wisdom, 2(2), 556.

Lipsey, M. W., Howell, J. C., Kelly, M. R., Chapman, G., & Carver, D. (2010). Improving the effectiveness of juvenile justice programs. Washington DC: Center for Juvenile Justice Reform at Georgetown University.

Majeed, M., Saleem, R., Ahmad, N., & Qudsia, B. (2024). Examining the Legislative Landscape: A Comprehensive Analysis of Juvenile Delinquency in Punjab. Bulletin of Business and Economics (BBE), 13(1).

Mbangowah, N. H. (2017). An ex post facto analysis of juvenile recidivism and the effectiveness of rehabilitation and incarceration University of Phoenix].

McNeill, F. (2014). Punishment as rehabilitation.

Miceli, V. (2009). Analyzing the effectiveness of rehabilitation programs.

Monarski, F. A. (1987). Rehabilitation vs. Punishment: A Comparative Analysis of the Juvenile Justice Systems in Massachusetts and New York. Suffolk UL Rev., 21, 1091.

Mueller-Smith, M., & T. Schnepel, K. (2021). Diversion in the criminal justice system. The Review of Economic Studies, 88(2), 883-936.

Nagin, D. S., Cullen, F. T., & Jonson, C. L. (2018). Deterrence, Choice, and Crime. Contemporary Perspectives. New York.

Olonisakin, T. T., Ogunleye, A. J., & Adebayo, S. O. (2018). The Nigeria criminal justice system and its effectiveness in criminal behaviour control: A social-psychological analysis. International Journal of Accounting Research, 3(6), 28-44.

Piquero, A. R., & Steinberg, L. (2010). Public preferences for rehabilitation versus incarceration of juvenile offenders. Journal of Criminal Justice, 38(1), 1-6.

Restrick, B. (2021). Theories of Responsibility and Punishment in a Causally Determined World.

Saeed, M. (2020). Improving Efficiency of the Court Service in Pakistan: A Comparative Study of the Options for Reform Newcastle University].

Shinnar, S., & Shinnar, R. (1975). The effects of the criminal justice system on the control of crime: A quantitative approach. Law & Society Review, 9(4), 581-611.

Siregar, I., & Rahimy, A. (2023). A Normative Analysis of Juvenile Sentencing Laws in Indonesia: Reconciling Justice, Rehabilitation, and Victim Redress. Polit Journal Scientific Journal of Politics, 3(3), 160-169.

Tonry, M. (2006). Purposes and functions of sentencing. Crime and Justice, 34(1), 1-53.

Ullah, Z., Shah, N. A., Khan, S. S., Ahmad, N., & Scholz, M. (2021). Mapping institutional interventions to mitigate suicides: A study of causes and prevention. International journal of environmental research and public health, 18(20), 10880.

Von Hirsch, A. (1992). Proportionality in the Philosophy of Punishment. Crime and Justice, 16, 55-98.

Ward, T. (2011). Human rights and dignity in offender rehabilitation. Journal of forensic psychology practice, 11(2-3), 103-123.

Ward, T., Yates, P. M., & Willis, G. M. (2012). Criminal Justice and. Criminal Justice and Behavior, 39(1), 94-110.

Warraich, K. M., & Butt, J. S. (2024). Revealing the Economic Consequences of Prosecution Failures Within Pakistan's Criminal Justice Systems: A Focus on Ethical Considerations, With Comparative Insights from Norway. Minhaj International Journal of Economics and Organization Sciences, 4(1), 1-23.

Weisburd, D., Farrington, D. P., & Gill, C. (2017). What works in crime prevention and rehabilitation: An assessment of systematic reviews. Criminology & Public Policy, 16(2), 415-449.

Wessells, M. G., & Kostelny, K. (2022). The psychosocial impacts of intimate partner violence against women in LMIC contexts: toward a holistic approach. International journal of environmental research and public health, 19(21), 14488.

Yousafzai, A. K., Sudfeld, C. R., Franchett, E. E., Siyal, S., Rehmani, K., Bhamani, S., Dai, Q., Reyes, C. R., Fink, G., & Ponguta, L. A. (2021). Evaluating implementation of LEAPS, a youth-led early childhood care and education intervention in rural Pakistan: protocol for a stepped wedge cluster-randomized trial. Trials, 22, 1-21.

Downloads

Published

2025-01-25

How to Cite

Ahmed, F. A., Irfan, A., Urooj, A. ., & Shaikh, H. L. . . (2025). Analyzing the Effectiveness of Rehabilitation vs. Punishment in the Criminal Justice System. Review of Education, Administration & Law, 8(1), 15-28. https://doi.org/10.47067/real.v8i1.400