Reforming Post-Arrest Bail in Pakistan: Lessons from a Comparative Study with India
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.47067/real.v7i4.375Keywords:
Bail, Criminal Justice System, Post-Arrest Bail, Liberty, Arrest, Bail ReformsAbstract
This research paper presents a comparative analysis of the legal frameworks governing post-arrest bail in India and Pakistan, with a focus on the statutory provisions, judicial interpretations, and procedural safeguards that are involved. Although both states share a common legal heritage which is rooted in British colonial law, however, they have diverged in their approaches to bail, which are influenced by their respective constitutional mandates, legislative developments, and sociopolitical landscapes. This comparison is essential in order to understand how these legal systems are balancing individual rights with societal security and how judicial discretion are shaping bail in each country. For this purpose, this paper examines constitutional provisions besides main statutory provisions of the Indian and Pakistani criminal procedural laws, the role of judicial discretion and evolving jurisprudence of the post-arrest bail. This study offers insights into potential legal reforms, with an aim to enhance fairness and consistency in bail practices, through juxtaposing these principles in India and Pakistan. This study concludes that Pakistan should consider restructuring its bail procedural laws and system, and it suggests reforms taking into account the benefits of India’s progressive legal framework, to ensure consistency, fairness, and the protection of individual rights. This research also recommends future studies on balancing bail and incarceration, through focusing on judicial discretion and the application of the principle of proportionality.
References
Ali, S., & Sadia, H. A. (2022). Analyzing the Adverse Effects of Delay in the Administration of Criminal Justice System in Pakistan. Pakistan Journal of International Affairs, 5(2). http://pjia.com.pk/index.php/pjia/article/view/666
Ami, Z., Begum, S., Irfan, N., & Anjum, S. (2024). Imprisonment Due to Allegations: A Comparative and Applied Study of Islamic Jurisprudence and Law (With Reference to Pakistan). Research, 4(7), 3212.
Anand, V. (2021). Protection of Accused under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution: A Critical Analysis. Indian JL & Legal Rsch., 2, 1.
Atta-Ullah v. the State 2024 SCMR 1210.
Bail and Bonds. (n.d.). Prosecutor General, Government of the Punjab. Retrieved October 19, 2024, from https://pg.punjab.gov.pk/bail_and_bonds
Barak, A. (2017). Proportionality stricto sensu (balancing). In Rights: Concepts and Contexts (pp. 507–538). Routledge. https://www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/9781315244129-28/proportionality-stricto-sensu-balancing-aharon-barak
Baweja, D. (2023). Judicial Discretion in Grant of Bail. Issue 1 Indian JL & Legal Rsch., 5, 1.
Bhalla, S. (2020). Bail Or Jail. Amazon Digital Services LLC - KDP Print US.
Carroll, J. E. (2020). The due process of bail. Wake Forest L. Rev., 55(1), 757–793.
Dhamija, D. A. (2009). Law of Bail, Bonds, Arrest and Custody (First Edition). LexisNexis.
Gul, P., & Ali, B. (2020). The Criminal Justice System in Pakistan. JL & Soc. Pol’y, 97.
Gurbash Singh Sibbia v. the State of Punjab AIR 1980 SC 1632.
Huscroft, G. (2014). Proportionality: Constitutional Rights and Their Limitations. Constitutional Commentary, 29(2), 229–256.
Itbar Muhammad v. the State 2024 SCMR 1576.
Kumar, B., & Kumar, A. (2020). Law relating to bail in India: A critical analysis. PalArch’s Journal of Archaeology of Egypt/Egyptology, 17(7), 10494–10506.
Locke, J. (1988). Locke: Two Treatises of Government Student Edition. Cambridge University Press.
Mairaj, M. U., Tullah, M. R. A., & Azeem, H. M. (2024). Fair Trial Rights of the Accused: Evaluating Compliance with International Human Rights Standards in Pakistan. Pakistan Research Journal of Social Sciences, 3(2). https://prjss.com/index.php/prjss/article/view/144
Malik Tariq Ayub v. Raja Arshad Mehmood 2022 MLD 2037.
Maqbool, A., Butt, S., Akhtar, N., & Azeem, H. M. (2024). Reforming Pre-Arrest Bail in Pakistan: Lessons from India. Pakistan Journal of Criminal Justice, 4(1), 211–222.
Mehmood, K., Sultan, M. S., & Azeem, H. M. (2024). An Analysis of Pre-Trial Fair Trial Rights and International Standards. Annals of Human and Social Sciences, 5(2), 627–637.
Mill, J. S. (2016). On Liberty. CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform.
Mst. Ishrat Bibi v. the State 2024 SCMR 1528.
Mughal, J. R. (2011). Law of Offence and Bail in Pakistan. Available at SSRN 1945643. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1945643
Muhammad Rafique v. the State 2024 MLD 521.
Muhammad Tanveer v. State PLD 2017 SC 733.
Muhammad Usman v. the State 2024 SCMR 28.
Muhammad Yaseen v. the State 2014 PCrLJ 1179.
Mukerji, R. K. N. U. (2020). Law of Bail (1st edition). OakBridge.
Nabi, M., Hussain, S., & Kamran, M. (2021). Overcrowded prisons in Pakistan: Understanding the critical role of probation, parole officers and courts. Pakistan Journal of Social Research, 3(01), 40–47.
Narula, R. K., & Mukerji, U. (2020). Law of Bail. OakBridge.
Nelson, G. L. P. author details . (1975). BAIL AND RECIDIVISM: A STUDY OF RELATIONSHIP. - ProQuest [Mphill, California State University, Long Beach]. https://www.proquest.com/openview/b8db970db057382e15288daefaa1ec3b/1?pq-origsite=gscholar&cbl=18750&diss=y
P.S.R. Sadhanantham v. Arunachalam (1980) 3 SCC 141.
Rahman, K. U., Khan, Z., & Khan, T. A. (2020). A Review on the Criminal Justice System: Understanding. Global Legal Studies Review, V(III), 33–38.
Raifeartaigh, U. N. (1997). Reconciling bail law with the presumption of innocence. Oxford J. Legal Stud., 17, 1.
Ram, U., & Kumar, P. (2021). Incarcerated population in India: How many are dying? How are they dying? International Journal of Prisoner Health, 17(2), 171–186.
Rani, M., & Praveen, R. (2022). Law Relating to Bail under Indian Law. Part 2 Indian J. Integrated Rsch. L., 2, 1.
Sagar, S., Kumar, V., Pathak, D. N., & Singh, M. (2022). Bail: A matter of right or discretion in the criminal justice system in India. International Journal of Health Sciences, 1(I), 431099.
Sah, A. (2023). Bail and Undertrial Inmates: Unveiling the Crisis within the Criminal Justice System. Issue 4 Int’l JL Mgmt. & Human., 6(1), 1118.
Salman Mushtaq v. the State 2024 SCMR 14.
Satender Kumar Antil v. the Central Bureau of Investigation (2022) 10 SCC 51.
Satya, A., & Kumar, N. (2022). Conundrum around the Right to Default Bail under Section 167. NLIU Law Review, 12(1), 43.
Shabbir, S. S. (2022). Delay Defeats Criminal Justice in Pakistan. Available at SSRN 4097930. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4097930
Shankar, K. K. (2022). A Research Analysis on the Overcrowding of Prisons. Part 1 Indian J. Integrated Rsch. L., 2, 1.
Sharma, S. K. (1980). Dimensions of Judicial Discretion in Bail Matters. Journal of the Indian Law Institute, 22(3), 351–370.
Shaukat Ali v. the State 2024 SCMR 594.
Sherwani, M. (2019). Rights of the Accused in the Legal System of Pakistan: A Legal Analysis. Islamabad Law Review, 3(3 & 4), Article 3 & 4.
State of UP v. Amarmani Tripathi (2005) 8 SCC 21.
Tarase, G. M., & Talawar, S. P. (2013). A study of rights and safeguards of accused in India. International Journal of Physical and Social Sciences, 3(8), 66–81.
Tariq, A. (2019). Deficient Monitoring Mechanisms Against Bail in Pakistan: A Challenge for the Protection of Rights of the Parties. Criminal Law Forum, 30(2), 225–240. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10609-018-09363-5
Tariq Bashir v. State PLD 1995 SC 34.
Thilagaraj, R. (2013). Criminal Justice System in India. In J. Liu, B. Hebenton, & S. Jou (Eds.), Handbook of Asian Criminology (pp. 199–211). Springer New York. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-5218-8_13
Tiwari, A. (2022). Overcrowded Prisons, Bail and the Legal Response-A Pandemic Perspective. Issue 1 Indian JL & Legal Rsch., 4(1), 1.
UPADHYAY, K. P. (2023). RIGHT TO AN ACCUSED PERSON UNDER JUDICIAL AND POLICE CUSTODY. A LANDMARK ON THE INDIAN CONSTITUTION, 413.
ur Rehman, T., Usmani, M. A., & Parveen, S. (2021). A critical analysis of the criminal justice system in Pakistan. Pakistan Journal of International Affairs, 4(4). http://www.pjia.com.pk/index.php/pjia/article/view/285
Vedantam, T. M. (1914). Bail in Criminal Law. Can. L. Times, 34(1), 660.
Vyas, K. (2023). Comparison of Powers of Criminal Courts in old code and new code. Available at SSRN 4394871. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4394871
Zafar Iqbal v. Muhammad Anwar 2009 SCMR 1488.
Zahid Mehmood v. ASJ 2021 MLD 947.
Zahoor, R., Arif, S. M. W. K., & Bannian, B. (2022). The Concept of Bail in Pakistani Legal System A Legal Analysis. Pakistan Languages and Humanities Review, 6(3), 413–424.
Zubair Ahmed v. the State 2024 PCrLJ 160.
